This is my open letter to my State Rep., Tan Parker, and my State Senator, Chris Harris, regarding public school funding.
Rep. Parker, schools in Texas are already struggling due to a flawed funding formula that failed to take growth and inflation into account. Expensive state and federal mandates have made it more expensive than ever to educate our children. Our local district, Lewisville ISD is already running lean, and there is little left to cut that will not affect the classroom. Under HB 1, Lewisville ISD stands to lose from $44 to $64 million in state funding it is entitled to under current funding formulas the state committed to for so-called "property tax relief".
Anywhere else in society, when someone promises to pay, then reneges, that is considered bankruptcy. The state of Texas is bankrupt due to a lack of revenue, engineered purposely, I believe to derail public education.
Not only is this bankruptcy in the fiscal sense, it's a kind of moral and spiritual bankruptcy to balance our budget on the backs of our children, and our teachers.
I think there are several things that need to be done, and I urge you to find the moral conviction and courage to do them, even though they run counter to the dogma-du-jour of your party:
1. Put STARR on hold until schools are FULLY funded, including textbooks. It is an unfunded mandate that will be impossible to achieve without a lot of curriculum staff in each district working full-time on it. When districts begin to fail these new tougher standards, it will be used as further fuel on the fire by those who believe public education is wrong.
2. Release the rest of the rainy-day fund - every last nickel of it. When you are bankrupt, you don't get to keep a savings account. That money rightfully belongs to the schools.
3. Allow districts to raise their local tax rates - without election - up to a rate that would bring them the same amount of revenue in total as the previous year.
4. Address the long-term funding shortfall by appropriately raising taxes. You don't get something for nothing, and there is a price to live and work in a state where people are educated. If we think paying a few dollars extra each year is going to kill us, then we ought to see what's coming when our state slips even further behind in educating our kids. The most expensive education is cheaper than the cheapest prison. Raise my taxes. I'm asking you to raise my taxes.
Update 4/6/2011: I received this response letter from Tan Parker today. I want to quote one particular sentence that struck me as excessive reaching for silver lining on this:
"In its current form, House Bill 1 appropriates 56% of all available revenue (total budget) to funding education programs in Texas. This percentage is in line with prior state budgeets and I am proud that even during these challenging economic times that the Texas legislature continues to allocate the majority of our resources to educating our children."
Can you see the fallacy in that? Funding the same percentage of a smaller pot, when the original commitment was for a larger amount is bankruptcy. I took a job 3 years ago that amounted to a 15% cut in pay for me. Do you think I could have called all of my creditors and just told them I'd be paying them less of what I owed, but that they should be happy because it's the same percentage of my take-home as before?
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
Poster
Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/3/28 20:05 Updated: 2011/3/28 21:16
Re: Failure to Fund is BANKRUPTCY
Steve, I am posting this question here because it has to do with the all mighty dollar! What do you think about GE not paying ANY Federal taxes last year?
I heard that story on the news the other day, and sadly it didn't surprise me. The huge multi-national companies play arbitrage with taxes in the nations where they operate. The rest of us don't have that luxury. As I understand it - and I'll admit I've not read up on the specifics of GE, but they had an overall profit, but claimed a loss on their US segments, and thus paid no taxes.
An achievable goal, short term, would be to rework the tax code to eliminate the common loopholes. Long term, I think we have to look at taxes from a global perspective and come together as a world community to quit allowing each nation to under-cut the next. How to do that, I have no idea.
I guess one thing we can all do is exercise our limited power as consumers to purchase goods and services from tax-paying U.S. companies, so that money comes back to us. But this is a prime example were self-interest (getting the lowest price) goes counter to our national interest (having a robust manufacturing economy, and collecting adequate taxes).
Poster
Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/3/28 20:20 Updated: 2011/3/28 21:17
Re: Failure to Fund is BANKRUPTCY
Great Job, Steve. I especially like your last 2 sentences. I think you should send a copy of this to the editorial section of several local newspapers.
Poster
Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/3/28 20:39 Updated: 2011/3/28 21:17
Re: Failure to Fund is BANKRUPTCY
Here! Here! I agree with all of the above.
- LISD parent and teacher
Poster
Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/3/29 6:50 Updated: 2011/3/29 8:39
Re: Failure to Fund is BANKRUPTCY
I totally agree. I can't stop to wonder who would actually benefit from cuts in education. Any city, state, or country should put education in a priority category. Seems like we are moving back in time...where only the wealthy could afford educating their offsprings and the rest (peasants) should not even be able to read and write. Maybe then it will be easier to sell a bunch of BS...
Poster
Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/3/29 9:57 Updated: 2011/3/29 9:58
Re: Failure to Fund is BANKRUPTCY
Bingo! And the next thing you'll see introduced is school vouchers so that the wealthy can pull "their" tax dollars out of the school system and pay for private school with it thus further decimating the public school system funding. That will be a sad day in this country if, instead of segregation by race as has occurred in the education system in the past, we have segregation by pocketbook!
Sure. I don't expect anything other than a canned form letter, but who knows - maybe it will give us some insight into why they think how they do.
Poster
Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2011/3/30 8:48 Updated: 2011/3/30 9:16
Re: Failure to Fund is BANKRUPTCY
I wrote to my state rep and Mr. Harris as well. I also stated that I will NOT vote for any politician in the future who supported these cuts. I think that is the only way they will wake up...the fear of not being re-elected.
Man what a long winded rant this is. Must have been pretty drunk too? Oh well, it is very good writing anyway. I guess it would not be much better when sober? You know Stephen they say that Edgar Allen Poe did his best writing when he wss under the influence of opium I believe it was. Please do not tell me you were smoking something too Stephen?
Regarding the update: Well Tan may be on the opposite side of the issue, but he does usually do well at acknowledging people and replying to stuff. He's one of those guys I wouldn't mind chatting with (as I've done before), as opposed to many other people on the other side of the aisle.
But you're right. 56% of the last budget and 56% of this budget are two very different things, and it means massive funding cuts to important programs. -BC
Yep, I do agree that Tan is typically someone who will hear you out, even though he is on the opposite side. I have to give him credit for coming to my door in 2008, even though I had an Obama sign in the yard. I really wish I had been home to talk to him then, but we've spoken since then.