Recent News and Opinion
2016/5/2 - City Council passes resolution defending and supporting Lewisvill...
2016/5/2 - Early voting ends Tuesday in LISD, city elections
2016/5/2 - Positive West Nile test prompts Lewisville mosquito spraying for T...
2016/4/30 - Team effort required for emergency management during severe storms
2016/4/30 - Art Review - "Just Bury It"
2016/4/29 - TEA Responds to Lewisville ISD on STAAR test issue
2016/4/29 - Lewisville police ask residents to report non-working street lights
2016/4/28 - Ozone Season Brings Heightened Air Quality Awareness
2016/4/28 - North Texas Blvd bridge demolition this weekend
2016/4/28 - DCTA to conduct mock disaster drill with Lewisville
2016/4/28 - Visual Art League update
2016/4/28 - Updated: Police investigate McGoys Marine for theft, announce town...
2016/4/27 - Video: Lewisville ISD candidates use forum to talk about issues, q...
2016/4/27 - Avanti Senior Living at Flower Mound to host welcome events with s...
2016/4/26 - Lewisville's emergency management team watches storms
2016/4/25 - Students to compete in Rotary speech contest
2016/4/25 - Journey to Dream to open shelter for homeless teens
2016/4/24 - Briefs for 4/24/2016
2016/4/23 - STAAR: All for the love of testing
2016/4/23 - Police department promotions, changes due to expected growth
2016/4/23 - Pets of the week
2016/4/23 - Rough week for Farmer softball and baseball
2016/4/23 - Paws in the Park adoption event Saturday, Apr. 23
2016/4/23 - Lake Park won't be open for Memorial Day weekend
2016/4/22 - Journal, Gazette team up for LISD candidate forum Wednesday, Apr. 27
Recent Reader Comments
2016/5/2 15:21 - Re: Video: Lewisville ISD candidates use forum to talk ab... (Anonymous)
2016/5/2 15:01 - Re: Place 4 LISD school board candidates answer questions (Anonymous)
2016/5/2 12:20 - Re: Video: Lewisville ISD candidates use forum to talk ab... (Anonymous)
2016/5/1 23:27 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/5/1 0:53 - Re: Video: Lewisville ISD candidates use forum to talk ab... (Anonymous)
2016/4/27 17:54 - TAMSA responds to STAAR grading problems. (WhosPlayin)
2016/4/27 12:37 - Re: Lewisville's emergency management team watches s... (jbcglc)
2016/4/22 8:53 - Re: Updated: Police investigate accidental shooting (Anonymous)
2016/4/21 18:38 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/21 7:23 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/20 22:46 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/20 20:44 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (WhosPlayin)
2016/4/20 18:31 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/20 9:52 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (WhosPlayin)
2016/4/20 5:54 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/20 1:55 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/19 23:00 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/19 21:30 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/19 20:37 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (WhosPlayin)
2016/4/19 19:14 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (Anonymous)
2016/4/19 18:55 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (WhosPlayin)
2016/4/19 18:38 - Re: Updated: STAAR exam vendor fails LISD students (WhosPlayin)

The Making of a Right-Wing Anti-Government Meme (and a turkey sandwich)

The Editor's Column
Posted by WhosPlayin on 2012/2/16 8:40:00 (1175 reads)

In the past couple of days, you may have heard a story going around, published by a right-wing think tank hyped by the paranoid and the right-wing talk radio crowd about an incident in a North Carolina. In the story, a "government lunch inspector" at a pre-school deemed a 4-year-old's sack lunch from home as not being nutritious enough, and forced her to have chicken nuggets and milk instead, sending her mother a bill for the lunch.

Wow, wouldn't that get your blood boiling? Government lunch inspectors? Really? Upon reading a rehash of the story on a Texas conservative news website, my first reaction was disgust at what seems like idiocy by a school district, followed by "hey, wait a minute...". I went to the original source of the article, which seems to be an original report, including statements from the child's mother. I thought about writing something last night about how the occasional overreach or isolated mistake by someone somewhere in government can manipulated to induce fear in a paranoid population that a given policy or action is widespread and on its way to crushing their freedom.

As it turns out, I'm glad I didn't write anything, because as usual, there is more to the story, as pointed out by The League of Ordinary Gentlemen. Another conservative outlet in North Carolina published its own version of the story that reveals a few more details: It turns out that the school was being inspected that day by a contractor for compliance with the North Carolina Division of Early Childhood Development. You see, this preschool is a voluntary free program for children "at risk" (low income or with learning issues).

As such, since the state funds the program, expecting the children to be low income, it requires schools to provide a "nutritious" meal. If a child's sack lunch is not enough, the school provides extra food to supplement it - not replace it. The inspector ordered full lunches for all students in the class.

Further, the mother says she hasn't been billed for the food, though she worries she might. The school's principal says that no parents will be charged.

Look, it's a valid thing for a pre-school program for poor kids to pay for and require a healthy lunch for the kids. For many kids, this could be the only nutritious meal they receive all day. All you can do is provide the meal; you can't force kids to eat it. And I would argue (as would this outlet) that milk products are not necessary to make a healthy meal.

And certainly, the intent of the program was not to second-guess the judgement of parents, who know what their kids will eat. Rather, it's got to be about making sure kids have enough to eat.

If anything, I think the lesson here is that despite the best of intentions on the part of lawmakers and government employees, there are people out there who will misinterpret everything in the worst possible way. Good communication with parents and the media is a school district's best defense against ending up with this type of situation getting blown all out of proportion.

I guess another lesson is to look at stories like this with a bit of skepticism and discernment, because too often they fit an anti-government narrative all too conveniently.

- Rating: 10.00 (1 vote) - {$lang_ratethisnews}
 
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.

Poster Thread
Anonymous
Posted: 2012/2/16 8:54  Updated: 2012/2/16 10:26
 Re: The Making of a Right-Wing Anti-Government Meme (and ...
I have a friend in Flower Mound that "jokes" about wanting Michelle Obama to stay out of her kids school lunches. I've asked her in the past if she understands that Mrs. Obama's initiative is to make healthier, less obese kids and that she doesn't have anything to do with the school lunches served in FM but she insists that she wants her to stay out of the school lunches. My friend is an intelligent woman but she watches Fox News and listens to extreme talk radio so that shapes her perspective on all things political. Steve, you have a good point about the school district needing to communicate to the public but, with hateful rhetoric on the airwaves meant to panic people, no matter how well the school district communicates someone will still try to twist the story to their benefit. We all need to wake up and not believe everything we see and hear regardless from which side of the aisle it came.
Reply

Poster Thread
WhosPlayin
Posted: 2012/2/17 9:45  Updated: 2012/2/17 9:45
Editor
Joined: 2008/12/12
From:
Posts: 4258
 Teacher's mistake on policy, says school
Associated Press has a followup on the story:
Quote:
The cafeteria details are true, but rather than an example of government “lunch bag police” overruling a family, it’s an embarrassing lapse by a teacher, Hoke County Schools Assistant Superintendent Bob Barnes said Thursday.

The girl’s teacher should have handed the child a carton of milk to round out the turkey-and-cheese sandwich and banana she brought from home. Instead, the teacher erred by telling the tyke to get a cafeteria lunch, Barnes said.

“We do not go over and stare down every child’s lunch,” Barnes said. “If you looked at the lunch the child had, I’d love to have that lunch today. However, there are occasions that kids bring lunches that aren’t that complete, and that’s why we try to supplement them with the things that they need to make it a complete lunch.”
Reply


Other articles
2016/5/2 22:30:00 - City Council passes resolution defending and supporting Lewisville ISD’s STAAR fight
2016/5/2 20:40:00 - Early voting ends Tuesday in LISD, city elections
2016/5/2 15:22:01 - Positive West Nile test prompts Lewisville mosquito spraying for Tuesday and Wednesday nights
2016/4/30 4:47:49 - Team effort required for emergency management during severe storms
2016/4/30 4:14:10 - Art Review - "Just Bury It"
2016/4/29 23:00:00 - Print Edition - 04/30/2016
2016/4/29 17:10:00 - TEA Responds to Lewisville ISD on STAAR test issue
2016/4/29 11:06:39 - Lewisville police ask residents to report non-working street lights
2016/4/28 18:27:54 - Ozone Season Brings Heightened Air Quality Awareness
2016/4/28 17:56:53 - North Texas Blvd bridge demolition this weekend


The Lewisville Texan Journal is a service of SagePost, Inc.
Login to Comment
User:
Pass:
Remember me
Lost your password?
Create New Account